Showing posts with label ancestry. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ancestry. Show all posts

Wednesday, October 2, 2019

Cemeteries....where else would you find your dead relatives?

Guest Blogger, Lisa Rienerth, Library Associate, Medina Reference


Friendsville Cemetery - Westfield Twp.


Woodlawn Cemetery - Wadsworth
Using gravestones and cemetery records can be extremely helpful when doing your family research.  They can provide information on a relative who lived and died prior to the state or county recording vital records; it may lead you to other vital records; and it is always good to have one more source to provide the proof for your research. Plus it is one of the few physical connections you will have with a deceased ancestor.

There are a few hurdles you may need to overcome when doing this type of research. First, the gravestone only provides the birth and death date, but you have to remember, this information, though carved in stone, may be incorrect. Tombstone carvers make mistakes. Also, it may be hard to find the final resting place of your ancestor and even if you do find it, the stone may be unreadable due to age and other damage.

Don't let these reasons discourage you. The following instructions will help with these hurdles.

Let's start with an online search.


Two websites that I use are Findagrave.com  & Billiongraves.com. These sites depend on members to upload memorials and photos.  Finding your relative on one of these sites can be a tremendous help. Even if there isn't a photograph of the tombstone, the information given for the memorial is helpful and it provides a name of the cemetery where you may find even more records. There is usually a map of where the cemetery is located, which is helpful especially with the small and out-of-the-way cemeteries.



Look for other online sources. Sometimes the cemetery is large enough to have their own online database and sometimes the city, county or state may have one. Sometimes I just google the name of the city/county/state with the word "cemeteries" and see what comes up. I just found Ohiogravestones.org, a site for the State of Ohio, the other day.

Different online genealogy sites can also be helpful. The main two I use are FamilySearch.org & AncestryLibrary Edition (through your local library). These type of sites are adding more and more cemetery records to their databases and digitized images. They also will link to other sites like Findagrave and Billiongraves.

If you don't know where or when your ancestor died, you can use the U.S. Census to narrow down your search. This is another source you can find on online genealogy sites like the ones I mentioned above (this type of research was covered in the MCDL Genealogy Blog on 3 April 2019). If you find them in the census records and follow them through the decades, whenever you come to a year they are no longer listed, this may be a clue to where and when they died. For example, George Smith was found in the 1850, 1860 & 1870 U.S. Census in Montgomery County, Ohio. He is not located in the 1880 U.S. Census in Montgomery County, Ohio or anywhere else. This may be a clue that he died between 1870 & 1880 in Montgomery County, Ohio. This isn't a definite answer, but it does zero in your research to a smaller area.

Another online source is Archive.org. This site will help you find transcribed cemetery records and find where the cemeteries are located.





Findlay Republican Courier - Newspaperarchive.com
Obituary and death records can also be found online through genealogy sites and databases.

You can search for obituaries in many of the newspapers that Kathy Petras talked about in her 7 August 2019 Blog. Sometimes the place of burial is mentioned in the obituary.






The more recent 20th century death records are more apt to have the cemetery listed than the pre-1900 records.

 




Cemetery records can also be found in libraries, archives, historical societies or government offices. You need to research the area where you believe your ancestor died and see which repositories are in the area and what types of records are kept there. For example, the Medina Library has a Tombstone Inscriptions book compiled by the Medina County Genealogical  Society. It is nice to have, because some of the transcribed tombstones are no longer readable.








The Western Reserve Historical Society is a local repository that owns not only local published cemetery records, but also out of state records. You can do an online search of their collection to see if they may have what you are looking for.























Trip Preparation


After using the above resources you should have a good idea of where you ancestor is buried. Now it is time to prepare for your visit to the cemetery. You may not be going to the ends of the world, but you need to take a few items to make the visit a successful one.






For more ideas on what to take, check out Your Guide to Cemetery Research by Sharon Debartolo Carmack.








O.k....you are packed and ready to go! Here are a few things to remember when you arrive...


Shaw Cemetery - Lafayette Twp.


  • Treat the area with respect and be careful of the markers.
  • Do not try to excavate or fix the marker.
  • When walking among the stones be careful where you step. The ground is not always level. 



Guilford Center Cemetery
Photograph more than just the tombstone....

Take one of the surrounding area to help you find the stone again if necessary.




Mound Hill Cemetery, Seville 
Take one of the tombstones around the one you found, these could be family members.



No headstone!?


You have walked the whole cemetery and you didn't find a tombstone...yet you know the person you are looking for is buried there....or you found the headstone, but you can't read it due to the fact that it is over 100 years old and the carvings have been worn smooth.

Do Not Fear! There are other places you can look! 

The Sexton, the person who looks over the cemetery and its records, may have the information you need. Even if you find a readable headstone, these records may give you even more information than what is on the tombstone. 

There is usually an office on the grounds of the cemetery. If there isn't one or you don't know if there is a sexton or not, go to the city or county offices. The Parks & Recreations office can usually tell you where those records are located or they may have them. If there isn't a Parks & Rec office, just check with the City Hall, they may at least be able to point you in the right direction.


Fostoria Fountain Cemetery, Ohio

The sexton or cemetery records may give you more than a name and dates. Sometimes it list other family members and sometimes cause of death.
Wilson Family Cemetery
Findagrave.com added by Medina County Graves, ID # 47506344

If the cemetery is affiliated with a church, contact the church to see if they keep the records. If it is a private family cemetery, you may need to get permission to search.








When you get home after your successful cemetery trip don't forget to download, identify & update as soon as possible! If you wait too long you will forget the details.




Searching for my ancestors in cemeteries is one of my favorite types of research. I hope you enjoy it and may all your searches be successful!


Sources:

All Medina County cemetery photographs, unless otherwise noted, were taken by me, Lisa Rienerth.

AncestryLibraryEdition, census records

Solether obituary, Findlay (Ohio) Republican Courier, 3 February 1966, page 24; digital images, Newspaperarchives.org.

FamilySearch.org, Ohio deaths, 1908-1953

Medina County Genealogical Society, Tombstone Inscriptions from the Cemeteries in Medina County, Ohio, 1983 (Evansville, IN: Whipporwill Publications, 1984).

Fostoria Fountain Cemetery, cemetery records, Fostoria, Hancock County, Ohio.


Bibiliography:

Findagrave.com

Ohiogravestones.org

Archive.org

Western Reserve Historical Society catalog (http://catalog.wrhs.org/collections/search)

Your Guide to Cemetery Research by Sharon Debartolo Carmack











Wednesday, April 3, 2019

U.S.Census Records

The fourth in the series of Instructional Genealogy Research Blogs

 - Guest Blogger: Lisa Rienerth, Medina Library Adult Reference Associate





The United States Census is an historical record of the entire U.S. population and one of the most extensive record sets for researching your family history. It provides a unique snapshot of your ancestor's lives and can provide a multitude of clues to extend your research. 

A Brief History 

The Census has been taken every ten years since 1790 through present times. The records are not made available for general public use until 72 years after they are taken. This is done to insure the privacy of the public. The 1940 census is the most recent census available and the 1950 census will be made available in April 2020. 

The census is taken to provide an accurate population count which is used to provide the correct number of  U.S. representatives for each state. It is also used to help estimate the amount of taxes to be collected. Some of the earlier census were used to count the number of available men for a standing army. 

Photograph from the U.S. Census Bureau
Keep In Mind

The people hired to go through the neighborhoods to take down the information were called Enumerators. Many of these enumerators were uneducated and mistakes did happen and houses were skipped.  You have to remember that some of the enumerators were collecting information in areas that were quite rural and some times it was easier to just ask one of the farmers in the area to give the information for all of the other families near his farm.

Be Prepared
Choose one family to research at a time. Make sure you know as much as possible about the family before you begin, i.e. ages, place of residency, names of children, etc.
Have at least 5 different ways to spell the surname. You have to keep in mind that surnames were not spelled the same every time it was written. The enumerator sometimes just wrote it phonetically or sometimes families just wrote it any way they thought it should be and sometimes not the same way twice. Don't be confused if it isn't spelled exactly the way you think it should be and don't be surprised if the person you are searching for goes by his or her middle name or even a nickname. You can use the information you already have on the person or family (birth dates, children's names, etc.) to confirm it is the family you are searching for. 



Where To Find Them
Photograph from the U.S. Census Bureau

The easiest way to search the Census records is to do it from a genealogy website. That's not to say there aren't other ways. Some libraries, the Medina Library included, have some of the census records on microfilm. It's just simpler if you can use a search engine to find the record you want. The top three that I use are, FamilySearch.org, Ancestry.com and Heritage Quest.

Family Search can be searched from any computer anywhere and is a free website. You need a subscription to search on Ancestry.com. However, Ancestry Library Edition is available for use within libraries and archives as long as it is one of their databases. Heritage Quest is usually available through a library or archive, but can be accessed even when not visiting that repository. The Medina County District Library's branches have both Ancestry Library Edition and Heritage Quest available for our members.

A Few More Things...

1. As with all genealogy research, you begin with the most recent date and work your way back.

2. All of the information you find is important to add to your family history, not just the vital statistics.

3. The information you find in the most recent census will give you clues on how to find other records including older census records. I am going to highlight which columns will hold this type of information.

4. Each census contains different requested information and the farther back in time we go, the less information is requested.

Let's Begin!  


1940 Census

Every census has a date the enumerator was supposed to use when asking about information. In the 1940 Census, the family was to answer every question as if the date were April 1, 1940, no matter if the date was after that or not. 

A blank census form will help you decipher what information you are seeing on the sheet. You can find them on FamilySearch.org or Ancestry.com. 

In the left hand corner of the census form you will find the state and county which is being enumerated. This is one of the clues to where to look for additional records.


Columns 1 & 2 shows the address and column 4 shows whether the house is owned or rented.

  • If the property is owned, there should be property records. You can search for land or deed records and use the address to aid in this research. 
  • Sometimes the information you find in a deed can be a gold mine. You might find a spouse, children and other relatives listed. 



Columns 7 & 8 - Name & Relation

  • Check every name & relation. Make sure it is the family you are searching for.
  • Look for different surnames listed in the household and check their relation to the head of household. These might give you clues to maiden names of the female relatives. For example, if the person listed is the male's head of household's father-in-law, the father-in-law's surname would be the head of household's wife's maiden name. 
  • Don't disregard the family if there is or isn't a name you recognize. Sometimes a family member is forgotten to future generations for one reason or another. It will be up to you to find out what happened to this family member. 

Columns 9-12 
  • The age will give you the approximate birth year. This will help when searching for other vital records, such as birth and marriage records. It will also help in finding earlier census records. 
  • If the person is listed as a widow/widower in the marital status column this gives you a heads up to look for a spouse in an earlier census and to look for a marriage record, possibly in the county and state they are enumerated in. 




Columns 15 & 16  - Birth & Citizenship

▶ This information shows if your family member was born in a different place other than where they are in 1940. You will search for earlier census records in the place of birth.

► It gives you clues to the family's migration, which leads to more places to search for records, including immigration records.



►Be alert to the child's birth place, it will show you where the family lived at certain dates. For example: a child is 10 years old in the 1940 census in Ohio, but it states that he was born in New York. Now you know that the family was living in New York at least 10 years ago. 

►Sometimes the place of birth changes with census records. This adds another place to search for records. It also means you need to find a different source to confirm the place of birth.

►The citizenship column asks if the person was foreign born and if so what was the country's name before 1937. The country's names in Europe were constantly changing after World War II began so the census gives the name before the war started.

►It also distinguishes between French & English Canadian and Irish Free State & Northern Ireland. This will help narrow down the area you need to search for records. 

►If the person is foreign born it will list the following:
  • Na - Naturalized 
  • Pa - Having first papers
  • Al - Alien
  • AmCit - American Citizen
If the person was Naturalized or having First Papers you can look for the naturalization record or the First Papers. If the person is listed as an Alien, you know they have yet to file for naturalization.

Columns 17- 19



►Helpful in finding records for families between the 1930 & 1940 census.

►If they lived in a different place in 1935 you may be able to find more records there. 


Columns 21-22

►Due to the Depression and Government Work, the government wanted to know more about employment status.

►Government Work meant the "New Deal" programs, such as the WPA (Works Progress Administration), the NYA (National Youth Administration) or the CCC (Civil Conservation Corp). 

►If you find that your ancestor worked for these agencies you can search the personnel records through the NARA (National Archives and Records Administration). 




Columns 28-33 - Employment Status


These listings may not provide information that will help find vital records for your ancestor but it will add to the story of your ancestor. Remember genealogy isn't just vital records, it is also history of the life your family member lead.


Lines 14 or 29 - Lucky You!
If your ancestor happened to be listed on the Lines 14 or 29, then there is additional information for you to find. These people are listed at the bottom of the schedule in Column 35.

Columns 36 -38 - Place of birth of father and mother and "mother tongue"
  • This will lead you to different areas to search for records, i.e. vital records, land records, census records. 
  • If they are foreign born you can start searching for possible immigration and naturalization records. Lauren Kuntzman will explain how to do this type of research in her May Blog. 
Columns 39-41 - Veterans
  • If the answer is Yes to column 39 & 40 and which conflict in column 41, this will help in finding military records. Kathy Petras will be covering military research in her June Blog.

Column 42 - Social Security
  • If the answer is yes, than you can request a copy of their Social Security application, if the person is deceased. 
Columns 48-50 - For all women who have been married
  • If she answers Yes, that she has been married more than once, you need to search for her other marriage record. You start by looking for it in the current county she is residing in.
  • You can use the age at her first marriage to figure out what year she was married. Just take her age now and subtract her first marriage age and then subtract that number from 1940. For example: She is listed as 50 years old in the census and she lists 20 years old as her age at her first marriage, when you subtract 20 from 50 you get 30. Then you subtract 30 from 1940 and 1910 would be the approximate year that she was married.
  • Remember if she said she was married more than once, this marriage record may be with someone other than who is listed as her husband in 1940. 
  • The number of children ever born also includes the children who have died after they were born. This may lead you on a search for a child that no one ever talked or knew about. You can search for them in previous census records or try to find a birth or death record using the parent's names. 

That was fun! Right?

Now you are going to use some of the information you learned from the 1940 census to help find your relative in the 1930 census. For example, if your relative lived somewhere different in 1935 according to the 1940 census, this is where you should begin searching for them. If they are listed as living in the same place you start searching in the same county and state for 1930.

You will find as you go back in time with the census records, that each census is a little different than the others. Sometimes the same question is asked, but the column is located in a different place on the schedule. Sometimes the information requested is the same on the previous census, so I am only going to go over the questions which are different and how you can use this information to find other records or why it is important for your research.  

1930 Census

The first difference is the census date. This time the enumerator asked the questions as if it were April 15, 1930.

Column 9 - Does the household have a Radio Set?

Photograph from the U.S. Census Bureau


This question was asked to see the feasibility of using the radio as a method of selling consumer items and as mass communication for a national emergency. It is not a question that will aide in finding other records, it is just kind of neat to see if your family owned a radio in 1930.



The following questions I am listing are different only because they are being asked to everyone, not just two people picked off the schedule. You can use the same methods I mentioned above to find the records.

Column 15 - Age at first marriage

If you see a difference in time span between the age the person presently is and the age they were at their first marriage compared to their spouse, this may indicate a second marriage and another record you need to find!

Example:





Clarence Swanson is 34 years old in 1930 and was 32 years old at the time of his first marriage. This means he was married for the first time around 1928. His wife, Sadie is 39 years old in 1930 and was 16 years old at the time of her first marriage. This means Sadie was married for the first time in about 1907. Sadie has another husband in her past. 

Columns 19 & 20 - Place of birth for Father & Mother

By knowing the parents birth place, you can now search for the following records:
  1. Immigration records if foreign born. 
  2. Earlier census records.
  3. Birth records. 

Column 22- Year of Immigration

It is extremely helpful to know the year your ancestor immigrated to the United States, because now you have a time period to look for these records.

Column 30 & 31 Veteran and What War? 

This data will help when searching for Military records.

1920 Census

This census is very similar to 1930. The census day is now January 1st, 1920 and there is only one additional question that will help in your research. The other information you will use the same way you did with the 1940 & 1930 census.

Column 15 - If Naturalized & Year of Naturalization

This narrows down the time period of when your relative was naturalized.  For example, if he/she were naturalized in 1918, it is more likely you will find the record in the county they are enumerated in 1920. However, if you cannot find it in that county, then check the county where they were listed in the 1910 census.


1910 Census

The census day is now April 15th, 1910.

Column 9 - Number of Years of Present Marriage
  • Take this number and subtract it from 1910 and find the approximate marriage year to aid in finding the marriage record. 

Column 10-11 - Number of children born & Number of children now living
  • Use these columns to make sure you have an account of all the children in this family, living or deceased, at the time of this census. The living children not named in this census may be living some where else and are enumerated in another 1910 census or an older census record. The children who have died may also be listed in previous census records. 
  • Now you also need to look for birth and death records for the unknown children. 
Column 30  - Whether a survivor of the Union or Confederate Army or Navy?
  • Again, this is helpful for Military records. 

1900 Census 

Census day is June 1st, 1900. 













This is one of my favorite census...yes, I have a favorite census record. This is why....

Column 7 - Date of Birth 
  • Not only does it list the persons age, but the month and year of their birth. This comes in handy when looking for birth records, especially if you are having problems with persons of similar names. For example, two John Smiths born in Medina County, Ohio, in 1880. By using the month you can possibly eliminate a John Smith. 
  • It also helps fill in those pesky blank spaces on your Family Group Sheet.
Column 18 - Naturalization
  • This gives you the date of your ancestor's naturalization. You can use this date to find his/her naturalization papers. Use the census records to see where they were living around the date of the naturalization and search in that county for the record.

1890 Census

Census day is June 2nd, 1890.

This is the sad census. Most of it was destroyed by fire and water damage in the Commerce Department where it was stored. Less than 1% survived.

Here is a list of places where fragments are found:

Alabama—Perry County

District of Columbia—Q, S, 13th, 14th, RQ, Corcoran, 15th, SE, and Roggs streets, and Johnson Avenue

Georgia—Muscogee County (Columbus)

Illinois—McDonough County: Mound Township

Minnesota—Wright County: Rockford

New Jersey—Hudson County: Jersey City

New York—Westchester County: Eastchester; Suffok County: Brookhaven Township

North Carolina—Gaston County: South Point Township, Ricer Bend Township; Cleveland County: Township No. 2

Ohio—Hamilton County (Cincinnati); Clinton County: Wayne Township

South Dakota—Union County: Jefferson Township

Texas—Ellis County: S.P. no. 6, Mountain Peak, Ovila
Precinct; Hood County: Precinct no. 5; Rusk County: Precinct no. 6 and J.P. no. 7; Trinity County: Trinity Town and Precinct no. 2; Kaufman County: Kaufman.

You can search these records on both Ancestry and FamilySearch.

If you are lucky enough to have a relative listed in these surviving records, this is the additional information you will find.

Line 2 - Veteran or Widow of a Veteran of the Civil War
  • Again this will help with looking for Military records and Pension records.
Line 8 - If married within the census year
  • If your person was married between 1 June 1889 - 31 May 1890, you now know to look for a marriage within this year and most likely within the county they are enumerated in 1890. 
Lines 22 & 23 - Personal Health
  • This information may help lead you to some lesser used sources, i.e. hospital, special school or institutional records. These records are hard to find and sometimes not open to the public. 
  • Even if you cannot find these resources, it does add that additional personal information for your relative.
The above information is also is true for Line 24, which is whether your ancestor was a prisoner, convict, homeless child, or pauper. 


1880 Census

Census day is once again June 1st, 1880 and will continue to be June 1st until the 1820 census. 

The 1880 census has just one question that is slightly different than the 1890 question.

Column 7 - Birth date 
  • Like the marriage question in the 1890 census, if the person was born within the census year, then a month was given.
  • Remember, with this census, the census year isn't January through December 1880. It is 31 May 1879 through 1 June 1880. 

1870 Census

Information to remember when using the 1870 census.
  • Due to the end of the Civil War, many former slaves are now enumerated. They could possibly be using their former owner's surname.
  • Column 20 is an interesting question. It askS if the male U.S. citizen of 21 years of age and older was denied the right to vote. This is due to the passing of the 15th amendment after the Civil War. 
  • The address and street number are no longer enumerated.
  • The relation to the head of household is no longer given. Don't assume the man and woman listed  together are man and wife. They could be siblings, in-laws or unrelated. The children listed may not be related to the head of household or to the woman listed in the household. 
  •  The place of birth for the person's parents is no longer listed. There is only a hash mark if they are foreign born. 

1860 & 1850 Census

These were the first of the census records that began listing everyone in the household. There is a lot less information requested, but you still find enough to aid in further research. 
  • If you see a male relative listed in the 1860 census, and is of an age to have fought in the Civil War, and he is not listed in the 1870 census, this man may have died in the war. This can lead you to search for military and pension records and possible death records. 
  • You will notice at the top of the form, on the left, it states "Free Inhabitants.." there are separate slave schedules in 1850 & 1860.


1790 through 1840 census....the early years...



These census aren’t detailed, but provide valuable information of where you can continue your research.
It does place the family in a specific area and it will help to distinguish your family from others with the same name, by comparing ages of people in household with what you have recorded. You can also locate possible additional relatives with the same surname.



Here is some information to keep in mind when using them for research.
  • Only Head of households are listed with other occupants of the household indicated by a hash mark that coincides with a span of year. For example, male between 10-15. 
  • The people are also separated by sex and race.
  • Beware that some people are listed alphabetically and some are listed as they were visited by the enumerator. 
  • The slave schedule is listed within these census records. It divides the slaves by gender & age. No owner's name is given.
  • In the 1840 census, Pensioners for the Revolutionary War are also listed by name and age. This will help determine if your ancestor was in the Revolutionary War and if there may be both military and pension records. 
  • Census day for the 1790-1820 census was the first Monday in August. 
  • Enumerators for the 1830 & 1840 census were provided printed schedules to record the information.
  • In 1790 through 1820 the enumerators had to provide their own schedules. Using a blank form is extremely helpful when researching these census, since many census takers did not label the columns.
  • With all of the census between 1790-1840, be aware that the age breakdowns are different census to census. 
  • There are also some missing census records. You can check at FamilySearch.org to find out which ones are missing. 


Now that you have gleaned all the information you can from these records take the time to compile and compare all the data for each family. You will find that the census provides a wealth of valuable information. However, you should not accept this information as proof of any fact or event. You use the census as a stepping stone to further research and to back up information you have already found and to add a little history to your family research.

Please let me know if you have any questions on these records. Ancestry.com and FamilySearch.org have some wonderful tutorials and articles on Census Records and I have listed a few resources below that provide additional information and aids to searching them.

Happy researching!



Sources:

Finding Answers in the U.S. Census Records - Loretto Dennis Szucs

The Source: A Guidebook of American Genealogy - Loretto Dennis Szucs & Sandra Hargreaves Luebking










Wednesday, October 7, 2015

DNA Testing Results


At the end of summer, my family took advantage of the reduced pricing on DNA testing from Family Tree DNA to get some more individuals tested. As Judy Russell of the Legal Genealogist Blog says "Test. Test as broadly and as deeply in your family as you can afford to test."

Both of my daughters now have been tested and two of my seven siblings also have been tested.

And it has been fascinating to see what the tests have revealed as well as what they haven't revealed.

I first became interested in DNA testing to help with a particular brick wall I have. Family lore tells us that my Great Great Grandmother, Emeline (ARTIS) SWAIN was three-quarters Cherokee. When I first starting researching my family history I interviewed relatives who knew Emily before she died and they all swore she was 3/4 Cherokee. And everyone pointed to my siblings with straight dark hair, brown eyes and darker complexions as evidence.


But no matter how much I searched, I couldn't find any written records that would corroborate  the story.

Emily Artis, on right, with her husband
 Otha Swain. Circa 1890's.


Emily's parents were Stephen ARTIS and Mary WALKER. The couple married in Montgomery County Maryland in 1829 and Stephen was in a militia unit for Washington DC in the War of 1812.  They have not been located in the 1830 census. Sometime around 1830-1835 they moved to Ohio, where Emily was born. Stephen reputedly died in 1837, but of course no death record exists for him. Mary is found in the 1840 and 1850 census with minor children. Searching in probate, land records and the DAWES Rolls for Cherokee connections have failed to turn anything up.




So, DNA testing to the rescue, right?? Maybe, maybe not. If Emeline was 3/4 Cherokee, as her Great, great granddaughter, I would be 3/64 Cherokee or slightly less than 5% Cherokee. That IS enough to show up on most DNA tests.

IF.

If everyone got exactly half of their DNA equally distributed from each of their parents. But DNA is much more interesting and tricky than that. You do get half of your DNA from each of your parents, but what half you get is pretty much up to nature.

And I apparently didn't get any of the Cherokee DNA from Emeline. My DNA results came back 100% European. Which wasn't too surprising, as I am fair complected and have blue eyes, like my mother's side of the family. But what about my brown eyed, brown haired siblings??


My first sibling to be tested was my oldest brother. He has the dark hair and dark eyes associated with our "Cherokee" ancestry. But his DNA results came back 100% European also. Puzzling...


One positive outcome was that we found out from his Y-DNA testing that our paternal JOHNSON's came from northwestern Ireland! We had no idea the Johnson line was Irish! Needless to say, we have not yet traced them back to the Emerald Isle. (Our farthest back Johnson was born in Kentucky in 1792.

My other sibling tested was a younger sister. She has hazel eyes and dark auburn hair. She seems to be a thorough mix of our parents - dark eyed, dark haired Dad and fair haired and green eyed Mother. Surely, with such a clear mixture of our parents, that Cherokee DNA would show up!?!


NOT!

She came back 100% European too!

So that is where we stand right now. No DNA evidence of Cherokee or Native American ancestry.

Does that mean the family lore is wrong?  Not necessarily. Remember that it is pure chance which of your ancestral DNA you inherit. We could get all of my siblings tested and none of them show up with Native American ancestry and it still wouldn't mean the family story is wrong.

BECAUSE OF THE TEST.

Not all DNA testing companies test the same chromosomes when they run their tests. And not all DNA testing companies use the same reference DNA to compare your DNA to. What do I mean by reference DNA?

That is their core DNA samples from around the world that they use to compare their users DNA. Because of the expense involved, they tend to focus their DNA samples on the presumed demographic of the people they think will buy their tests. So it is heavily weighted towards western European DNA. And not so much less numerous peoples.

Also, the test results are estimates based on what a formula each company has. And it can only compare DNA results with people living today. They are NOT comparing our DNA to people who lived a hundred or two hundred years ago. You know... our ancestors.

Judy Russell of the Legal Genealogist blog explains in much better in her September 2013 post here:
DNA Disappointment.

Next week I will talk about what the DNA tests did reveal...